By Jon Cassidy | Watchdog.org
HOUSTON — Some of the most powerful politicians in Texas mean to impeach Wallace Hall, a regent of the University of Texas System, for asking too many questions about legislators pulling strings to get kids into college.
They can’t admit that’s why they want to shut him up, so they have worked themselves into a fever of unrighteous indignation over some obscure lawsuits.
In tremulous tones, they accuse him of a crime most foul: He didn’t fill out a form correctly.
Their outrage is contrived. The only thing uncommon about Hall’s disclosure form is that it actually discloses lawsuits, and is accompanied by a letter offering “a comprehensive review” of all his litigation with “as much detail as required.”
Watchdog.org decided to do its own comprehensive review — of every undisclosed lawsuit involving an appointee to a state university or educational board.
We got to 9,291 cases, give or take, before throwing up our hands. They ranged from piddling credit disputes to stuff that’s hard to forget, such as antitrust lawsuits brought by the U.S. Justice Department.
Only two officials in state history have been impeached, so you know Hall is doing something uncommon to provoke such a reaction. It’s not that he summarized his legal history rather than list every case by name. That’s the accusation, but if that was really grounds for impeachment, most of the regents would have to be impeached, Watchdog.org has found.
The thing that makes Hall unusual is that he dares to question the influence-peddling taking place in the Legislature.
Don’t expect the cynics in the Legislature to get too upset about these other undisclosed lawsuits. Hundreds of them involve two regents on their side. But for the past few months, they’ve been making quite a fuss.
State Sen. Kevin Eltife pronounced himself “disturbed.” Rep. Jim Pitts, the House Appropriations chairman, called on Hall to resign, and when that failed, he started impeachment proceedings.
“Clearly this was withheld. It would seem to indicate Mr. Hall felt like it was disqualifying for his nomination,” State Sen. Kel Seliger said a few months ago. “Withholding that, I think, is a very, very serious thing.”
We skimmed through hundreds of pages of applications to various state boards, spot-checking for lawsuits against the companies run by these applicants, almost always finding something.
Just on the board of regents for The Texas A&M University System, every voting member but one had something that should have been disclosed and wasn’t.
Regent Cliff Thomas attached to his application a seven-page printout of every lawsuit involving his businesses. That’s the level of detail that lawmakers are now pretending to demand, but Thomas is the exception, not the rule.
Elaine Mendoza, the CEO of Conceptual MindWorks, Inc., said she had no litigation to disclose on her 2010 application, but in 2009 her company was sued by Prompt Medical Systems.
Anthony Buzbee mentions two malpractice suits against him — without including names — and some evictions that his property company pursued. But he doesn’t list some minor federal cases in which he was a plaintiff. He also denied that he had ever been investigated by a state regulatory agency, although the Texas Bar and its Louisiana counterpart looked into complaints against him in 2004 — finding nothing, it would appear, as he has a clean public disciplinary record.
Judy Morgan checked a box saying that no company of hers had “been involved in any bankruptcy proceeding,” although her Jack B. Kelley Enterprises had been in a bankruptcy case the year before, as a creditor. There’s no shame in that, of course, but Hall is being dragged through the mud for a lawsuit that he filed and won, too.
Jim Schwertner’s Schwertner Farms has pursued debtors in bankruptcy court, too, as has Schwertner State Bank. He had checked “not applicable” for the litigation question, and no to bankruptcy proceedings.
John D. White’s Standard Renewable Energy Group has sued Chevron (not disclosed) and his Murphree Venture Partners has been in bankruptcy proceedings as a creditor.
Phil Adams is on the board of American Momentum Bank, which has been involved in 37 federal civil and bankruptcy cases.
Charles Schwartz, who has been a partner at two prominent law firms, acknowledged that he would have a material interest in any lawsuits against the firms, although he didn’t list the lawsuits by name.
He was right. We found 150 federal cases overlapping with his time at Vinson & Elkins and Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP.
Unlike most applicants, Hall actually did list his major lawsuits by name. Whoever leaked Hall’s application to the Texas Tribune clearly did not include the letter to the governor’s appointments office, which Hall attached to his application.
“There was a question on the Appointment Application that did not provide enough room for a comprehensive response but I wanted to address it now,” Hall wrote. “Per the question of litigation, I have during the course of business in my capacity as a fiduciary both as an investor and operator been involved in litigation from time to time in addition to the two cases listed. Much of this has involved eminent domain lawsuits. I am happy to provide as much detail as required, if you and your office so desire to review it in its entirety.”
It turns out that the governor’s office wasn’t interested at all in hearing about a fight over pipeline in the wetlands. Gov. Rick Perry’s appointments office received both the application and the attachment on Jan. 29, 2008. Two days later, Kenneth Anderson, director of governmental appointments, wrote back, assuring Hall the office would “contact you if we need additional or updated information during the appointments process.”
Morris Foster, a regent at the Texas A&M system, would get the death penalty under the new standard, as he was a vice president of Exxon Mobil Corp. and president of its development and production companies. He didn’t disclose any lawsuits, and if you want to guess that Exxon Mobil gets sued a lot, you’d be right.
The only question is how many thousand counts you want to charge him with.
This is the question he answered in the negative: “Have you, your spouse, or any company in which you or your spouse have a material interest been party to litigation? If yes, give details.”
The question doesn’t ask whether the lawsuit is material to Texas A&M, or even material to Foster’s own wealth. It’s asking about any litigation involving a company he has a stake in, which may explain why so many applicants flub their answers.
Under state law that determines whether a regent has a “substantial interest” in a company, Foster had such an interest three times over, as an employee, elected officer and holder of more than $25,000 worth of stock.
Foster was president of Exxon Upstream Development Co. when Exxon and Mobil merged Nov. 30, 1999. When he retired in 2008, he got $12.1 million in restricted stock options, and already owned nearly three times that amount of stock.
A search of federal court records from Dec. 1, 1999 through April 10, 2013 — when Foster filed his most recent application, a month after his reappointment was announced — turns up 8,027 lawsuits naming Exxon Mobil Corp. as a party.
The problem isn’t unique to Texas A&M, or education appointees. We checked out Dr. David Teuscher and Fred Heldenfels IV of the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board and regents Steven Hicks and Robert Stillwell of the University of Texas System.
Heldenfels listed a personal lawsuit against his homebuilder and three disputes involving his company, although he didn’t name the parties, so it’s hard to know which of some 48 cases involving his company he’s referring to.
Most of the lawsuits against Heldenfels Brothers — the name under which the family business he runs operated for nearly a century — stem from the infamous 1989 Alton bus crash, which killed 21 schoolchildren. His company made the guardrails.
Teuscher, is a partner at the Beaumont Bone and Joint Institute, which had been sued at least 27 times in state and federal court at the time Teuscher filed his application.
On his 2012 and 2013 applications, Teuscher’s answer to the litigation question is “professional liability and business interests only. None in over five years.”
That wasn’t strictly true. From 2007-12, at least six lawsuits were filed against Beaumont Bone & Joint Institute in state courts, by plaintiffs Norma Schroeder, James Zagone, Ted Slaughter, Amy Modica, Justin Brewer and Jacqueline Freeman. Another patient tried unsuccessfully to sue in federal court.
The group of lawmakers persecuting Hall has two friends on the UT Board of Regents who consistently support Bill Powers, the president of the University of Texas at Austin.
These two regents — Stillwell and Hicks — also have failed to disclose lawsuits in which they had a material interest – Stillwell a few dozen, Hicks nearly a thousand.
Stillwell answered “no” and “not applicable” to the litigation question on his 2009 form, yet he had an interest in at least 31 lawsuits at the time, and since he joined the board, he’s been personally named as a defendant in 11 more state and federal lawsuits.
Stillwell was a party to five lawsuits in 1995, three of them state and two federal. He was divorced in a Harris County court in 1980.
Stillwell was a founding partner of Mesa Petroleum in 1964 — along with T. Boone Pickens — and was a director of the company until 2001. Federal court records list 21 cases involving Mesa Petroleum in that time, not counting appeals.
On his application, Stillwell reports being director of Warren Equipment Co., a Caterpillar dealer in Dallas, which had been sued in federal court at least four times in the previous two years and a half years, not counting related cases.
Hicks, the chairman of an investment firm called Capstar Partners LLC, is best known as a radio mogul whose stations ultimately were merged into the behemoth known as Clear Channel Communications in a $23.5 billion deal.
When AMFM Inc. of which Hicks was the vice chair, merged into Clear Channel Communications, Hicks’ Capstar Broadcasting Partners got some $3 billion worth of Clear Channel stock, according to SEC filings and shareholder notices.
Hicks and his brother Tom, whose finances were often interwoven, stayed invested in Clear Channel for more than five years.
So for starters, you’d count every lawsuit involving Clear Channel filed between Oct. 4, 1999, and May 9, 2005. The federal database lists 750 cases — some of them duplicates — in that time.
Add in 39 distinct federal civil lawsuits involving AMFM Inc. and related entities. Then add 20 distinct federal civil suits involving SFX Broadcasting, which Hicks built, sold, reacquired a year later, and eventually merged into Clear Channel.
Hicks has used the name Capstar for business entities for decades. A search of the federal courts database turns up 167 cases naming Capstar, although scores of them are clearly unrelated to Hicks.
Then there are the companies that Capstar Partners owns now. Harden Healthcare was sued in 2008 by the U.S. Justice Department after a home-health aide at one of its subsidiaries claimed that she was forced to participate in defrauding Medicare and Medicaid by doing yard work and errands during nursing visits.
Hicks was on the board of HealthTronics Inc., from 2002 to 2010. The company was involved in 13 federal lawsuits during that time. DMX Inc., which Capstar controls, has been in three federal lawsuits and five bankruptcy cases.
Hicks was personally named in the bankruptcy of Urban Box Office Network Inc., which spanned much of the past decade. He was divorced in a Texas court.
On his 2009 application, Hicks didn’t mention any of these cases, instead checking the “not applicable” box.
When he submitted another application 22 months later, for his reappointment, he decided to mention litigation that he hadn’t included before. He mentioned a fight with a venture capital group called Syncom over a failed business called ClickRadio, as well as a lawsuit some homeowners had filed over road access near a lodge his company runs in Montana.
That was it.
Contact Jon Cassidy at [email protected] or @jpcassidy000.
- Texas’ Rep. Pitts announces retirement after improper influence story
- University of Texas regents show support for Wallace Hall
- Case against UT regent Wallace Hall is a sham — here’s proof
- Texas senator got $477k for supposed ‘cameo’ appearance in Wallace Hall lawsuit
- Lawmaker admits pulling strings on UT admissions
- Trustee accused of crime for rejecting dodgy accounting
- Longhorns: Senator used clout in UT law school admissions
- Children of Texas lawmakers get into UT School of Law, but struggle to pass bar exam
- Chancellor is probing favoritism in UT admissions
- UT report: Charge against Hall is legally ‘absurd’
- Attorney in UT case hides six-figure charges despite terms of contract
- University of Texas clout scandal grows as new e-mails surface
- Four more get into UT Law despite low LSATs
- Reports on UT favoritism, impeachment expected soon
- Attorney: Secret tape covered up by lawmakers proves regent’s innocence
- Dozens of UT Law’s least qualified students are connected politically
- University of Texas uncovers admissions corruption, halts investigation
- UT admissions: Straus, Branch, Pitts pulled strings
- Who got the 128? UT Law admits students with bad LSAT scores
- Patrick’s win may doom Hall impeachment effort
- Chancellor promises complete investigation of UT admissions
- Board to decide UT president’s fate Thursday
- Texas politicians smarten up, ditch UT pres this time around
- Tribune story may have doomed UT’s Powers
- Academics condone the privilege they denounce
- Three essential stories on the UT admissions scandal
- Texas AG Greg Abbott embraces Roe v. Wade
- Roe v. Wade is AG’s new pretext for blocking Texas law school investigation
- Two UT regents pressed for records destruction
- New crime invented for Hall: assisted guesswork
- Texas lawmaker failed to disclose his own clout letter in UT flap
- Texas legislator Fischer insists on role in UT investigation
- Hutchison pulled strings for friends’ kids and grandkids at UT
- Ex-UT Law dean’s credit card bill: $400k in four years
- Abbott’s UT picks are pro-affirmative action
- Report: University of Texas showed favoritism to thousands
- Kroll ignored hundreds of weak UT applications
- Billionaire defends UT admissions privileges for ‘leaders’
- Weak admissions to University of Texas Law increased after Sager’s ouster
- Kroll report takes dig at Watchdog.org
- Hicks won’t stop UT’s backdoor admits
- Texas governor’s wife was on UT nominee’s payroll
- Bill to limit UT oversight clears committee
- UT regent blasts speaker for ‘abuse of office’
- Texas politician rebuts himself with apparently plagiarized letter
- Pay-to-play scandal involves UT dean, Texas Exes
- Supreme Court asked to look at UT’s backdoor admissions program
- Lawmakers want UT applications shielded from scrutiny
- McRaven makes UT scandal his own
- An open letter to Attorney General Ken Paxton on the UT cover-up
- Chancellor Bill McRaven’s UT cover-up has no defenders
- UT’s back door still open, but can’t stay secret, AG rules
- Whitewash: Kroll left dozens of bad LSATs out of UT report
- McRaven’s defense to Hall lawsuit refuted by own words
- Ready for the end of affirmative action?
- UT admissions scandal is 10 times bigger than official report
- McRaven trolls Dallas Morning News
- Powers to get top salary at UT Law
- UT sues to block Watchdog access to admissions investigation
- UT approves ‘Spinal Tap’ policy for backdoor admissions
- Admissions survey: No, UT, everybody doesn’t do it
- UT admissions scandal prompts new investigation
- Ticket scandal a black mark for UT, DA
- Showdown over UT cover-up nears end
- McRaven’s rationale for UT cover-up denounced by regents, AG
- High court to decide if University of Texas can deep-six investigation
- High court hears arguments on whether UT can bury investigation
- Testimony by UT contradicts story fed high court
- These ‘horns ain’t loyal, McRaven finds
- UT’s Hall challenges Abbott over board picks
- Texas Supreme Court nullifies rule of law; impunity to reign
- The battle for the Kroll records goes on