Home  >  Opinion  >  Idaho’s Land Board has no business competing with the private sector

Idaho’s Land Board has no business competing with the private sector

By   /   October 21, 2013  /   No Comments

PRIEST LAKE: Looks like the state desperately wants to acquire more land.

PRIEST LAKE: Looks like the state desperately wants to acquire more land.

By Wayne Hoffman | Idaho Freedom Foundation

Forgive me if I don’t take a lot of comfort in the Idaho Land Board’s decision a few days ago to reject a plan to exchange 69 cottage sites on Priest and Payette lakes for $25.5 million in commercial property.

The Land Board’s decision is great. But the underlying problem remains: Our government, for all its hooting and hollering about supporting conservative values, can’t help but be an integral, if unwelcome, part of the marketplace.

Heck, the state of Idaho owns commercial real estate throughout Idaho, including a storage business, and has poured tons of money into a downtown Boise bar. The state desperately wants to acquire more land.

I’ll be convinced the Idaho State Board of Land Commissioners —which includes the governor, secretary of state, superintendent of public instruction, controller and attorney general — are sincere when the board swears off the notion that it’s OK for the government to own business enterprises. It hasn’t done so to date.

The Department of Lands wanted to swap the cottage site properties for commercial buildings in Idaho Falls and an office building in Nampa. The agency said the land trades would mean more money for Idaho’s public schools. But critics, me included, have argued that purchases would take the property off the tax rolls, leaving a greater burden on other taxpayers to make up the loss in revenue.

Other criticism involves whether the appraisals for the building being swapped were on the up and up. And that seems to be where the Land Board choked on the deal.

The Department of Lands has not backed away from its belief that engagement in the marketplace — being a landlord and business owner — is not a bad thing. Printed on all the department’s land swap documents are these words: “The state will not undercut the commercial real estate market with its rental rates because the IDL must charge market driven rents. Like state endowment owned forests that compete with privately owned lands in the sale of timber, the IDL must charge a market price for the use of the asset.”

It’s that kind of warped thinking that gets us in trouble and should terrify anyone in business.

The government — the state government, lauded for its sense of conservatism — believes that by charging “market-driven rates” it will not undercut its competitors. So, as long as the state charges the same prices for automobiles, hotel rooms and cans of beans, the state can enter any line of business without harm to the private sector, whether they are car dealers, hoteliers or grocers. That’s clearly a bucket of bull.

If government participation in parts of the economy is good for Idaho and its schoolchildren, clearly we should be doing more of it. Considerably more. The state is only limited by its availability of money and imagination.

Of imagination, the government has plenty, including the concept that the state’s ownership of commercial real estate isn’t truly “government ownership,” it is “endowment” or “trust” ownership. Those be two separate things, don’t ya know.

Such impaired thinking makes me believe the land exchange proposal in due time will be back before the Land Board. The appraisals will be validated, and our so-called conservative executive branch officials will dive in. Idaho businesses will lose, taxpayers will lose and another vestige of free market capitalism will be destroyed, right here in “conservative” Idaho.

Wayne Hoffman is the president of the Idaho Freedom Foundation


Wayne Hoffman is one of Idaho’s leading experts on public policy, the Idaho Legislature and the practice of journalism. Wayne has spent 25 years writing about government and politicians, and is often invited to speak on complex issues including taxation, health care, free markets and education. Throughout his years in the news business, Wayne won numerous awards for investigative and political journalism. During his years of covering the state legislature, governor’s office and state agencies, Wayne often exposed government waste, failed government programs and politicians whose voting records were inconsistent with their rhetoric. Wayne has been at the helm of Idaho Freedom Foundation since the organization launched in January 2009. He lives in Nampa with his two children.