Update: Congressman’s ad claim challenged by fact checker

By   /   October 15, 2012  /   11 Comments

Joe Jordan | Nebraska Watchdog

October 17, 2012  2 p.m.

Two days after Republican Congressman Lee Terry insisted that the Hill-Terry bill—legislation aimed at energy independence—”became law” a non-partisan fact checker is challenging Terry’s claim.

“I wouldn’t go that far,” said Julia Michaels, Legislative Research Director for Project Vote Smart.

Michaels tells Nebraska Watchdog it would be more accurate to say “some provisions from the Hill-Terry bill became law.”

On Monday during Terry’s first of two debates with Democrat John Ewing, Ewing challenged a Terry TV ad which says, “Congressman Lee Terry offered the bipartisan law that helps move America to energy independence.”

“Hill-Terry did not become law,” said Ewing.

Terry quickly responded, “Hill-Terry became law…it became law.”

According to Michaels, Hill-Terry, technically known as HR 2927, ”didn’t even make it through committee—the House just incorporated some of the provisions…into its main energy bill.”

Joe Jordan | Nebraska Watchdog

October 15, 2012 9 p.m.

Congressman Lee Terry took the blame Monday night for at least some misinformation in one of his campaign ads.

During the first debate (see video below) between Terry and Democrat John Ewing, Terry said, “I didn’t fact check my fact checkers.”

Terry’s comment came just hours after Nebraska Watchdog (see story below) reported that the seven term congressman’s campaign manager admitted that mistakes were made in a commercial regarding energy independence. 

Joe Jordan | Nebraska Watchdog

October 15, 2012 6 p.m.

A second Lee Terry TV ad is under fire and following questions by Nebraska Watchdog, Team Terry is admitting some mistakes.

Terry’s campaign manager tells Nebraska Watchdog, “I did not cite the TV ad properly.”

The ad—which first ran several weeks ago—says the Republican congressman from Omaha “authored the bipartisan law (Public Law 110-140) that helps move America to energy independence.”

In an email to Nebraska Watchdog, Dave Boomer, Terry’s campaign manager, acknowledges that “the final bill (PL110–140) was not the same” as the legislation known as “Hill-Terry” that is noted in the commercial.

Boomer also says, “I did not cite the TV ad properly.”

The ad claimed that the Union of Concerned Scientists called Hill-Terry “historic.”

But according to Boomer the UCS had actually tied the word historic to Public Law 110-140. Boomer tells Nebraska Watchdog, “I also had attributed to UCS that they called Hill-Terry “historic” when, in fact, the reference was made to the final law that passed…”

At the same time Boomer says Terry was a leader on energy independence and played a key role in getting Congress to raise fuel economy standards from 25 mpg to 35 mpg.

According to Boomer, Terry’s 2007 bill (HR 2927) would have set the levels between 32 mpg and 35 mpg by 2022, while the final bill which came out of a House-Senate conference committee approved 35 mpg by 2020.

Boomer tells Nebraska Watchdog, “Lee should share in the credit…as we save on imported oil…”

The flap over the energy ad followed questions on another Terry ad which accused his opponent, Democrat John Ewing, of being a big spender as Douglas County Treasurer.

That ad is no longer running.

Contact Joe Jordan at joe@nebraskawatchdog.org.

To subscribe to News Updates from Nebraska Watchdog at no cost, click here.


YouTube

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Please, feel free to "steal our stuff"! Just remember to credit Watchdog.org. Find out more

Joe Jordan

  • laugh or cry?

    The Union of Concerned Scientists has asked Terry to pull this ad because they called the 2007 Clean Air Act “historic” (not Terry’s dead-end bill). Campaign manager ‘Boomer’ screws up another ad for Butthead. Butthead is so ineffective he has Boomer run a 2012 ad for an itty, bitty bill he co-authored, in 2007, five years ago! The Clean Air Act, passed in 2007, has nothing in it representing Butthead’s itty, bitty bill that never made it out of committee (read the history of the Act). Should we laugh or cry Butthead is the laughing stock of Nebraska, in DC? What did you do in 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011 and 2012, Butthead? Is this the best the Republican Party in Legislative District II can offer us? No wonder 40-50% of the electorate doesn’t vote!

  • Malinda Frevert

    If Terry’s a “leader” in energy independence, where does he stand on President Obama’s demand that fuel efficiency standards increase to 54.5 mpg by 2025? An act that would save more fuel than the Keystone XL pipeline which Terry has so recklessly tried to push on Nebraskans.

  • VALLEY

    AND TO THINK THE PEOPLE OF THE 2ND DISTRICT WOULD SEND THIS CLOWN BACK TO WASHINGTON ONLY CONTINUE TO SCREW UP EVERYTHING HE CAN FOR THE PEOPLE OF NEBRASKA. FACTS AND LOGIC ARE NOT PART OF HIS OVERALL PLAN.

  • Rodney Callahan

    This silence is Golden. I can’t wait to read the republican response.

  • http://www.facebook.com/lisa.hannah.7773 Lisa Hannah

    Funny is that we exposed this very same lie back in 2008 at New Nebraska. Terry’s campaign manager defended it back then, too:

    http://www.newnebraska.net/diary/1182/
    http://www.newnebraska.net/diary/1187/
    http://www.newnebraska.net/diary/1191/
    http://www.newnebraska.net/diary/1193/
    http://www.newnebraska.net/diary/1199/
    CLAIMS 1, 2 & 3 were all said to be part of Public Law 110-140. Terry voted against the House Committee version of the Energy Bill while still in committee. He voted against H.R.6 all the way until the last step. He voted for the amendment he introduced into H.R.3221, but then voted against the overall bill. In the end, the only vote of support that occurred was the final vote. Until that point, Terry fought the formation until the very end.

    http://www.newnebraska.net/diary/1338/

  • Joan

    Lee Terry said last night that to increase taxes on the rich would cost jobs….There you go again you idiot, THE TRICKLE DOWN THEORY DOES NOT WORK! You also stated the House passed the jobs bill but that the Senate vetoed it…You failed to mention that it did not PASS BECAUSE OF THE ABSURB ATTACHMENTS THE REPUBLICANS PUT ON IT. And lastly the Stimulis was a huge success and Nebraska benefited from it, You on the other hand are not smart enough to know when the people in your district are recovering from Grover Norquest, George Bush and Dick Chaney’s lousy plan for the upper 1% and to which Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan will carry forward and allow this Country to turn into another 47% in poverty & the rest rich.

  • L.A.

    The way you keep your facts straight as a leader is to tell about your accomplishments while serving “we the people” instead of ripping your opponent a new one. The trouble with politicians and their political hacks is that the lines of what advertising is and isn’t have been blurred by the eagerness to use it as an excuse to sling mud and slam the other guy. The idea Burger King sells more burgers by telling us that McDonalds makes a lousy burger is goofy. Some say negative advertising works as if to defend the process and they may be correct, but it also decays the process. This is the same ole garbage that has been getting worse and insults voters. Tell people what you’ve done and what you intend to do to make their life better. By now? Congressman Terry should be above the mud instead of stuck square in the middle of it trying to find his way out. Again.

  • TLC

    Had Senator Ernie Douglas (Lee Terry) followed through on his big promise when he ran for his first term we wouldn’t be here right now. Senator Ernie Douglas was more than happy to champion TERM LIMITS. Where did that go? Seven elections later and we are still filling one of our U.S. congressional seats with and empty suit. In this case the nut DID fall far from the tree.

  • Joan

    L.A., the problem here with Lee Terry is he is not a leader that can talk about his accomplishments while serving cuz he has none. He simply is a drone for the Tea Party who continues to put him back in office election after election because he does as he is told to do while he rakes in a boat load of money and a retirement that most of us will never see, especially if Romney is elected.

  • Watching_From_Lincoln

    The easiest way for Terry Lee to avoid lying every time he opens his mouth is to leave his head firmly up his ass at all times and NOT remove it to make comments or commercials!

  • Watching_From_Lincoln

    He slept in his office and with a lobbyist!