Home  >  Iowa  >  IA: Voter registration overstated in Iowa county lists

IA: Voter registration overstated in Iowa county lists

By   /   October 25, 2012  /   87 Comments

By Sheena Dooley | Iowa Watchdog

DES MOINES – Every person living in eight largely rural Iowa counties is registered to vote, while another county has more registered voters on its rolls than citizens, according to a new WatchdogLab.org analysis.

An additional 26 counties had voter registration rates of 95 percent or higher – the same percentage of state residents on voter rolls. Compared to other states, Iowa’s 95 percent registration rate in the past two presidential elections is relatively high, according to the group, which is owned by the Franklin Center for Government and Public Integrity.

Secretary of State Matt Schultz

Some state voter registration officials, however, say the number is overly bloated due to lengthy steps to remove a name from the list required under federal law. It can take as much as eight years before a county auditor can remove a registered voter from the list. A number also argue the state’s outdated lists make Iowa’s 99 counties more vulnerable to voter fraud and impersonation at the polls.

Iowa election officials have to check various forms of ID to confirm a voter’s identity if they are no longer active on the rolls, meaning he or she hasn’t voted in the past eight years.

“We can’t just take people off at the drop of the hat,” said Carol Robertson, Mills County auditor and president of the Iowa State Association of County Auditors. “They don’t go off our registers until we have verification.”

Earl Glynn, a researcher at WatchdogLab.org, looked at registered voters in Iowa, both active and inactive, and compared them to population figures from the U.S. Census. Some counties had bloated lists because officials had yet to remove people who died, moved out-of-state or simply stopped voting, election officials said.

Iowa is one of a number of states that tried to pass proposals requiring voters to carry photo IDs with them to the polls. Lawmakers, however, never passed the tighter rules.

That hasn’t freed Iowa from joining a list of other states intertwined in election controversies.

Republican Matt Schultz, secretary of state, faces a lawsuit from two minority advocacy groups in the state for what they allege was improper use of his power to enact emergency rules. Schultz adopted emergency rules in July allowing his office to vet voter lists by matching potential non-citizens to a federal database that provides up-to-date immigration statuses.

He also signed off on a contract with the Iowa Department of Criminal Investigations, in which his office is paying as much $280,000 in the next two years to hire a full-time investigator.

A Polk County judge in the matter denied Schultz’s request to dismiss the lawsuit because the two groups lacked standing. She then issued an injunction halting Schultz from taking any further action until the matter was settled in court.

Despite that, an investigator from DCI is still investigating the lengthy list of potential non-citizens and has brought election misconduct charges against at least five people in the past month.

“Iowa is a politically active state,” said Sarah Reisetter, director of elections for the secretary of state. Part of that is because we have the Iowa caucuses and a high turnout in presidential years.”

Fremont County, a western county in Iowa with about 7,300 residents, had 105 percent of its voting age-population registered to vote in 2010-11.

Counties with 100 percent registration rates include: Cass, Ida, Jackson, Johnson, Kossuth, Lyon, Madison and Pocahonta.

“I don’t think it compromises the election,” said Joan Kirk, Fremont County auditor. “I don’t think it’s just that easy. They have to say where they live. I’m not saying it couldn’t happen, but there area all kinds of things that could.”

Reach Sheena Dooley at dooley@iowawatch.org.

Please, feel free to "steal our stuff"! Just remember to credit Watchdog.org. Find out more

Sheena Dooley

  • denise dao

    I just want Obama to win, it’s a close race but pray to God each day Obama will be the nex’t President of the United States He cares, Romney is not for me and or the POOR!!

  • Rick Michaelsen

    With all the rampant voter fraud lately in the country, we NEED a law that states a voter must present a valid, government issued picture ID to be able to vote.

  • Solja

    Matt Schultz is what’s fraudulent in Iowa.

  • Annie

    You need an ID to fly, drive, buy cigarettes, buy beer, do your banking, write a check, get utilities, why all the fuss to have an ID to vote?

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Bob-Clark/100001991467944 Bob Clark

    Strange. In the Primary Election last time around. Not only were our Voter ID Cards invalid, our Drivers License not recognized, and our names not on the print-outs, but we were for all practical purposes “non existent.” Good thing our neighbors knew us and we were able to vote on Provisional Ballots. We had to re-register and obtain new Voter ID cards… but our Drivers Licenses were still OK.

  • Phil

    I just learned tonight that my daughter (out of state in college) could technically walk into the polls in MN, provide her student ID, and vote in MN. That isn’t a big deal, except that she already voted absentee in Iowa. Yes, it would be illegal…..no, she isn’t going to do it. But, the point is that SHE COULD. How many out of state college students could and potentially are voting twice? At the very least, we should have a National database that keeps track to ensure double voting across state lines isn’t taking place. Shouldn’t be that hard, should it?

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1059009582 Steven Vince

    If you mean the nationwide republican effort to remove and/or block eligible voters from exercising their constitutional right to vote, having a gov’t issued picture id won’t address that.

  • http://www.facebook.com/obdoc1974 James Potter

    Damn, you Libs are like a broken record on this; the purpose of the ID is to keep Dems from voting for their dead Grandma, their dog, themselves twice, you get the picture

  • john

    the fuss is they are charging people to get a photo id 8.00 in some cases and it is a right to vote for free. i would have no issue if the ids were free

  • john

    also i live in iowa and every year i vote they make me produce my voters registration card which i got when i got my drivers license or my drivers license. ever time i have voted in every election since i was old enough to vote.

  • Kate

    I voted early at the Warren County auditor’s office and asked if I needed to produce an ID and was told no. Just stated my name and address and they got a ballot for me and I voted.

  • Veronica

    Because the right to vote is guaranteed to you in the election. The right to fly on planes or pay bills is not. What if you had to show a photo ID every time you wanted to exercise your right to free speech or religion?

  • Veronica

    Oops. I meant guarantee to you by the Constitution!

  • http://www.facebook.com/adam.genkinger Adam Genkinger

    As well as Republicans… they are a house full of criminalistic, ideological pigheads these days… lie, steal, and cheat to obtain the maximum benefit for ones self. Independent is where the future is heading… I believe this will be the last two party presidential race we will see.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=14823102 Jonathon Struve

    You idiot conservatives who think they have a monopoly on patriotism and fair play really love to gerneralize the conduct of nearly half of this country. Of the counties with 100 percent of voters registered, some of them are HEAVILY Republican counties, like Lyon. I suppose you’re worried about the Repugnantcans doing the same thing?

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=14823102 Jonathon Struve

    No it shouldn’t be.

  • douglasmarks

    Actually your individual states dictate your right to vote, not the constitution, some states allow felons, some do not, some states allow persons in prison to vote, some do not.

  • http://www.facebook.com/hobart.schmenge Hobart Schmenge

    All U.S. citizens should required to have a barcode tattooed to their wrist, connecting them to a Federal computer database. The barcode could then be scanned to vote, provide identification, purchase goods and services, allow the government to track your every move…

  • smoke and mirrors

    “Because the right to vote is guaranteed to you in the election.”

    And that means they can’t make sure the right person is voting why?

  • cyndi

    I agree with you Annie!!!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Lee-Sturgeon/100000172276290 Lee Sturgeon

    “Rampant”? Where did you hear that? I have read many, many stories reporting that voter fraud was practically non-existent, which of course further supports the obvious, and that is that Nationally Republicans decided to do all that they can to obstruct low income and minority voters because they tend to not vote for Republicans.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Lee-Sturgeon/100000172276290 Lee Sturgeon

    The picture, my friend, is that the only recent reports of voter irregularities, not counting legislators and governors trying to stop us from voting, were the recent stories of callers telling people the wrong date for the election, and telling others that they could vote by phone right now and so they won’t need to go to the poll on election day, or telling people that they are not allowed to vote because they were removed from the list so don’t bother going to the polls. Wait until we read about some indictments for that kind of voter fraud.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Lee-Sturgeon/100000172276290 Lee Sturgeon

    Actually, in most states that would not work. When she goes to vote in MN and fills out the paperwork to register, one of the things that they ask is where were you registered before. They do then notify that prior state to remove that person since they now registered in MN, and if Iowa got such a notice and it was for someone who already did vote here, they would notify MN and she would be in trouble.

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Lee-Sturgeon/100000172276290 Lee Sturgeon

    I read that book, but the bar code was on the forehead and it contained all of your medical information too.

  • http://www.facebook.com/mills1scott Scott Mills

    The right to vote is NOT guaranteed in the Constitution.

  • ashybeck

    just moved here fom SC and before I could tranfer my drivers license,I had to have birth certificate AND social security card.

  • ashybeck

    I also registerd to vote soon after, and had to only provide drivers license.How m fraudulent licenses are floating around with non citizens?

  • Combinder

    Even getting a library card requires photo id!
    Sensible voter id requirements will ensure free and fair elections. Proof of citizenship must be required to prove eligibility.
    Otherwise, our election process is corripted.

  • Helen

    Photo id’s don’t stop the type of fraud that the Repubs claim they want to stop. It’s voter suppression, plain and simple.

  • Annie

    I think I have seen these exacts words on different boards…word for word ummmmm

  • AnybodySeenGWB43?

    Our election process is *already* completely ‘corripted.’

  • AnybodySeenGWB43?

    There’s MINIMAL Voter Fraud on both sides.
    There’s MASSIVE Voter Suppression on the Right side only.
    Anyone who tells you different is lying to you.

  • http://www.facebook.com/thea.nicholas Thea M Nicholas

    who will pay for this? big government?

  • http://www.facebook.com/thea.nicholas Thea M Nicholas

    examples, please…

  • http://www.facebook.com/thea.nicholas Thea M Nicholas

    not many///but, let us know when you find an actual, verifible accounting…

  • http://www.facebook.com/thea.nicholas Thea M Nicholas

    any thing that requires an exchange of money=poll tax; free id’s, fine, but who pays for them and how do they get distributed and who keeps the data up to date?

  • http://www.facebook.com/thea.nicholas Thea M Nicholas

    yup..voting machines, chads, voter suppression, voter intimidation by employers…

  • http://www.facebook.com/thea.nicholas Thea M Nicholas

    why the rush? if this has been a long running problem with a long history, then why now? and why in such a constrained time frame? something smells here….

  • http://kibblesbits.wordpress.com/ Ann

    I don’t need ID for banking, to buy cigarettes or beer, to get utilities, or write a check unless I do that in person. However, because I never changed my social security info when I got married 22 years ago, I had a hell of a time getting replacement ID when I moved to Iowa. I could have missed an election, and had all sorts of headaches. Thankfully, I was able to vote.

  • http://kibblesbits.wordpress.com/ Ann

    In Dubuque, you DO NOT NEED photo ID for a library card. Please don’t spread lies around.

  • http://kibblesbits.wordpress.com/ Ann

    You must be reading weird news stories, because ID isn’t the problem with voting at all.

  • http://kibblesbits.wordpress.com/ Ann

    It’s hard to get the license without a social security card, but you can get state ID without it.

  • Combinder

    Goodness gracious. I meant no malice, Ann. Bless Iowa.

  • FarmGirl112055

    Obama had to show an ID to vote in Illinois the other day.. What’s wrong with doing that here?? You have to have an ID to get into the Dr’s office.. bank, fly, everything now except the one of the most valuable rights we have as CITIZENS.. Get a grip you maroons..

  • http://www.facebook.com/FrogGirl Chelle Adkins

    Unless of course she lies and said she was never registered before. If she were in MN voting when she already voted absentee in IA, what makes you say she’d be honest about where she was registered before.

  • http://www.facebook.com/FrogGirl Chelle Adkins

    Um. I moved to IA from NC and had to provide nothing to transfer my license.

  • http://www.facebook.com/maggie.tamulis Maggie Tamulis

    I thought about leaving a comment but if I told anyone what I know to be true I would be preaching to the choir…and..if I tried to point out that voting for Obama will be the worst thing you can do for our country…well it wouldn’t do any good because you are all hypnotized by Obama’s charm and his elequent lies and it is so sad..but…why bother because you guys wouldn’t hear me anyway now would you…!!!

  • farmboy

    you really think that obama cares about the people, pull your head out of the sand. I hate to see what the next four years will look like, guaranteed it will not look like the U.S. once did

  • http://www.facebook.com/Suzieq531 Sue Ripley

    Maybe some of you should realize that there are factory’s out there who take numbers from truck drivers SS cards & DL to give to illegal aliens so that they can pay them & allow them to work so they can get by not having union workers. Those same illegals are using those numbers to get cc & other things they need ID’s for, this is why it is so important that people have to use ID’s to vote, so they can make sure that the real people are using their rights as citizens & illegals aren’t.

  • http://www.facebook.com/Suzieq531 Sue Ripley

    besides the fact that, I have not found anything that does not require an ID, even using your cc at Walmart requires ID.

  • PAULA

    When I went to get my absentee ballot at the auditor’s, she didn’t even need to see my Voter ID Card, much less my Photo ID. Scarey to think someone could go in, say they’re me and get an absentee ballot, before I showed up…

  • Guest

    In Des Moines, you DO need ID for a library card.

  • prairieflower2

    Have to start somewhere!

  • prairieflower2

    Big Brother.

  • prairieflower2

    they aren’t trying to remove and/or block eligible voters—-only ones who are not eligible. What is the problem with that? I don’t want non-citizens voting in the US

  • prairieflower2

    The Republicans didn’t try to take God out of their platform.

  • prairieflower2

    I don’t agree with you.

  • prairieflower2

    You are so misguided in your thinking.

  • prairieflower2

    Wisconsin requires bc and soc sec # to transfer license

  • L

    Iowa’s County Auditors go through numerous steps to ensure that people who register to vote are eligible to vote and that they only vote once in any election.
    Could someone lie and vote in two states? Yes, they could. But it would take registering in both states and traveling to both or getting absentee ballots (which are probably the weak link in any voter ID law anyway). And all to cast one vote. I’m personally more concerned about the reports of companies hired to register voters by a political party that falsify voter registration forms in order to get paid or discard voter registration forms from people who have declared membership in the other political party. Hasn’t happened in Iowa, but has in Florida and other states.

  • NON voter

    At the ripe young age of 65, i have voted “once” in my life… show me “any” politician that isn’t a frigging crook, and i’ll vote again.

  • http://www.facebook.com/aaron.garrett.31 Aaron Garrett

    In Iowa City you DO. In Coralville you DO. In North Liberty you DO. For the record.

  • http://www.facebook.com/aaron.garrett.31 Aaron Garrett

    If you dont need an ID to vote because it is your right, then why do I need one to buy a gun?

  • http://www.facebook.com/aaron.garrett.31 Aaron Garrett

    If you don’t need an ID to vote because it is your right, then why do I need one to buy a gun?

  • http://www.facebook.com/bic.bicbickel Phil Bickel

    Voter integrity is largely on the honor system, and if a reporter like O’Keefe can go out and find it relatively easily, especially from official campaign organizations like OFA, then it is likely the tip of the iceberg. These people need to be prosecuted, and perp walked, and if that’s voter suppression in your eyes, then I suggest you may be part of it yourself. The vote is sacred, the alternative is spilling blood in the streets. Clear Channel was forced to take down billboards for simply stating that voter fraud is a felony punishable by imprisonment. The race groups claimed it was voter suppression, well, yes it was suppressing illegal votes.
    The integrity of the voting is sacred!

  • http://www.facebook.com/bic.bicbickel Phil Bickel

    You need an ID to buy Spray Paint in Columbus. Google Morse Road Early voting station Columbus Ohio. Voter fraud is rampant.

  • BA_Cyclone

    What line of the Constitution did you find that, exactly?

  • cheech

    Libs love to spend money so why not just have Uncle Sam pay for it? Problem solved, right?

  • BA_Cyclone

    Chelle Adkins: I don’t believe you. Iowa *requires* proof of identity, proof of residence, and proof of social security to get an Iowa driver’s license, even if “transferring” from out of state. (there is no transferring I.D.) http://www.iowadot.gov/mvd/ods/newresidents.htm This is a FEDERAL guideline for issuing state licenses.

  • http://www.facebook.com/loyal.winborn Loyal Winborn

    You do need to state your name and address everytime you address a City Council, a Court Room, or a State or National Congressional or Senate Meeting. You must be prepared to show ID at all of those functions to use your freedom of speech. Town hall meetings and politicol ralleys do not need IDs, but to speak to an elected official in office for freedom of speach or not, does require the ability to prove residencey in the area of that person’s or body of governing officials district. Many people from outside state and city lines try to influence votes and public officials often ask to verify residencey for citizens concerns.
    I have been on City Council for five years now, and people do state their name and address in every public forum in our meetings per the National Open Meetings Act. We have to publish who states what in every open meeting we have by Federal Law. Only in closed session are people allowed to speak in private on public matters, and there are few reasons we can go into closed session, and it rarly happens in our area.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=504262067 Arash Yarpezeshkan

    They’re probably Republicans.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=504262067 Arash Yarpezeshkan

    Maybe but who’s doing to drive or fly to two states to vote? It could happen but unlikely.

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=504262067 Arash Yarpezeshkan

    Many poor and elderly people don’t drive and can’t afford ID.

  • FarmGirl112055

    Government IDs are provided free of charge whether you drive or not. If you go to the correct place depending on the state.. My Mother- In-Love has an ID, she doesn’t drive.. and she is 90.. Nice try Arash.. Your argument doesn’t hold water..You are making excuses..

  • Keenan Webb

    Please state the section of the Constitution that guarantees you the right to vote (hint, it’s the 10th amendment). The 2nd allows, no guarantees, gun ownership. ID is required.

  • Keenan Webb

    No thanks to the bar code, that’s what our SS# was supposed to be for (identification). That’s turned out awesome. /sarc

  • ToucheTurtle

    Well shuckie darn . . . let’s change that oversight right away!!! After all, you never know when an imposter might steal a library book and use it to vote for the POTUS!!!!

  • ToucheTurtle

    BECAUSE the “big boys” say so!!! Of course, remember that if you have a GUN, then you are probably considered a threat to society . . . and they want to put your name in the National Registry so they know where to find you!!! I agree with you . . . why should I have to show my ID to buy a gun. It is a RIGHT given to us in the Second Amendment

  • ToucheTurtle

    And it could sure eliminate a lot of problems with the new health care bill. Just think . . .you could go into the emergency room, have your wrist scanned and be in a room in five minutes . . . UNLESS you are deemed unfit for treatment by the “Life or Death panel.” Then they send you out back by the dumpster . . . I am quite sure there is a pickup service on a daily basis!!!

    But the good news is . . . NO paperwork, no mess, no fuss! Good luck – hope you are worthy of receiving the care you deserve.

  • ToucheTurtle

    Those who are WORKING!!!! In lieu of collecting enough tax money from the dwindling work force to pay for this additional expense, they can always just endless print more money. Or find someone new to tax!!!

  • ToucheTurtle

    Many poor and elderly people get assistance from the gov’t, and I KNOW they have to show ID to qualify!!! The bottom line is: no ID = NO VOTE!!!!!

  • ToucheTurtle

    Well, you may be right but what is to say that they registered Republican and then VOTED Democrat!!!! You are too easy!!!!

  • ToucheTurtle

    You may very well get a real close-up view of what “being poor” looks like because whether you like it or not, this guy’s record for “creating jobs” which improve the economy is BAD!!! So your wish has come true . . hope you like the fruits of your prayers to GOD!!!!!

  • ToucheTurtle

    Do you even KNOW what a Republican is???? Just sayin’ . . .

  • calvin

    Had a democrat here in NC that said he had already voted for O 4 times and was looking forward to voting for him again on Nov 6th. Voter fraud is very real!

  • calvin

    It was reported by the Civitas group during early voting that 9000 votes were recorded from 112 year old women in our state. Problem is, they were dead!

  • calvin

    And the Black Panthers standing in front of the voting area asking voters if they’re voting for Obama is an example of what? In 2008 and 2012 both