Home  >  Nebraska  >  Nebraskans debate whether to expand Medicaid

Nebraskans debate whether to expand Medicaid

By   /   February 28, 2013  /   13 Comments

By Deena Winter | Nebraska Watchdog

LINCOLN – Two dozen people testified Thursday in support of a bill expanding Medicaid in Nebraska – as is optional under Obamacare – that is being promoted by a coalition of Republican and Democratic lawmakers.

Sen. Kathy Campbell, R-Lincoln, sponsored the bill despite vocal opposition to the proposal by Republican Gov. Dave Heineman. States can opt in or out of the provision expanding Medicaid to those earning up to $26,344 for a family of three.

“No matter what you think of the (Affordable Care Act), it is the law of the land,” Campbell said.

The federal government would cover all the costs from 2014 to 2016, after which its contribution would drop to 90 percent. Heineman opposes the move because he doubts the federal government will follow through on its funding promises, and he says the move would cost Nebraska hundreds of millions of dollars.

Kathy Hoell testifies before the Health and Human Services Committee in Lincoln, Neb., Thursday, Feb. 28, 2013, in favor of a proposal to expand Medicaid in Nebraska. (AP Photo/Nati Harnik)

Kathy Hoell testifies before the Health and Human Services Committee in Lincoln, Neb., Thursday, Feb. 28, 2013, in favor of a proposal to expand Medicaid in Nebraska. (AP Photo/Nati Harnik)

Campbell said if Nebraska doesn’t participate in the program, it would forgo $2.3 billion, and Nebraskans’ tax dollars would be spent on patients in other states.

“It is a way to stop writing a blank check for the ever increasing costs we all pay,” Campbell said.

A study by the University of Nebraska Medical Center estimates 55,000 Nebraskans would be newly eligible for Medicaid if the bill passed, resulting in an average of $750 in savings on private policy premiums for individuals and $2,100 for families through 2020.

However, Grand Island Sen. Mike Gloor pointed out that insurers won’t necesarily reduce premiums.

Jennifer Carter, director of public policy at the left-leaning nonprofit Nebraska Appleseed, said expanding Medicaid would grow the economy and allow people with disabilities to earn a little more without losing their coverage.

“It simply is the right thing to do,” she said.

The Nebraska Medical Association estimated about 500 Nebraskans wouldn’t die needlessly because they couldn’t get health care coverage.

However, Mike Grone of the Western Nebraska Taxpayers of North Platte, said the nation is broke, and this program would extend benefits to people who don’t have the motivation to take care of themselves – “deadbeats, I call them,” he said. He said the hearing proved “the people who show up are the ones who benefit from a government program.”

But Sharon Lind, CEO of Ogallala Community Hospital, said Nebraska should not “leave billions of dollars on the table,” and that expanding Medicaid would reduce the amount of bad debt, uncompensated care and charity care hospitals extend annually.

The bill was supported by the Nebraska Association of County Officials, the Nebraska State Education Association, the Center for People in Need, hospital representatives, pediatricians, a medical student, a nurse practitioners’ association, the Center for Rural Affairs, the Nebraska Association of Behavioral Health Organizations and the Nebraska Catholic Conference.

Gloor worried that all those newly insured would make it more difficult for Medicaid patients to get in to see a doctor.

“This is a setup for major misery,” he said.

Jessica Meeske, a pediatric dentist from Hastings, acknowledged her practice could become a dumping ground for patients if other providers don’t take the new patients.

“But we’re going to find a way to make this work,” she said. “We’re here to serve the vulnerable population.”

Kathy Hoell, who uses a wheelchair, said about 14,000 disabled Nebraskans would qualify for Medicaid if the bill passed.

Monica Scheehanartz, a hairstylist and single mom who has an illness that prevents her from being able to get health insurance, said if the bill passed, she would qualify for Medicaid.

“You’re one of those people that’s just one accident away,” Omaha Sen. Bob Krist said.

Vivianne Chaumont, Director of Nebraska's Medicaid program testifies before the Health and Human Services Committee in Lincoln, Neb., Thursday, Feb. 28, 2013, in opposition of a proposal to expand Medicaid in Nebraska. (AP Photo/Nati Harnik)

Vivianne Chaumont, Director of Nebraska’s Medicaid program testifies before the Health and Human Services Committee in Lincoln, Neb., Thursday, Feb. 28, 2013, in opposition of a proposal to expand Medicaid in Nebraska. (AP Photo/Nati Harnik)

State Medicaid Director Vivianne Chaumont testified against the bill, saying mandatory provisions in Obamacare are already estimated to add about 48,000 Nebraskans to the Medicaid rolls through 2020, at a cost of $770 million. If the bill passed, a total of 95,000 more Nebraskans would use the program, at a cost of $2.7 billion (both state and federal).

If one in five Nebraskans end up covered by Medicaid, access to care could be squeezed, she said, with health care providers either limiting or refusing to see Medicaid patients, creating pressure to increase rates. She also made it clear she works for the governor, so his priorities are her priorities.

However, Krist said her numbers didn’t add up.

“What we’re after really is the truth, and I don’t think the truth is on the left or right side,” he said.

Contact Deena Winter at deena@nebraskawatchdog.org. .

Editor’s note: To subscribe to News Updates from Nebraska Watchdog at no cost, click here.

Please, feel free to "steal our stuff"! Just remember to credit Watchdog.org. Find out more

Deena Winter

  • thinking smart

    Should have taken the cornhusker kick back would have paid for all of this.

  • D. Mark

    Does anyone realize that no matter if the money comes from the State or the Federal Government, it comes out of the taxpayers pocket? Washington has no money, they have to borrow over forty cents on the dollar. People need to know that we cannot continue on the path Washington is on, to give support for everyone.
    Some people are in need, but remember some people, the more that is given to them, the more they expect. Our leaders must know the difference!!!!!

  • Kevin

    As long as the takers continue to elect politicians that keep them poor, nothing will change.

  • Jazzee

    amen

  • Jazzee

    you mean we got this nightmare obamacare garbage and old ben nelson did nothing for the state of Nebraska???? wow surprise surprise so glad he is gone and now Johanns gone..hopefully we can elect some people with common sense

  • ToucheTurtle

    The grand scheme for this administration is to get as many people on the gov’t dole as they can. Dependency makes the masses an easy target because few can resist a “freebie!” Once the masses receive their new “benefits,” the POTUS can be sure that they won’t want to give them up, and then it is only a short way to raised taxes to support the increases in the programs. WHO pays those taxes? The folks who are working their butts off just to keep their heads above water, OR the new recipients of the gift from Obama? Is there truth to the old saying, “The more they get, the more they want”?

    I am surprised that there are folks here in Nebraska – people born and raised here – that don’t recognize that all of us are already paying more taxes than many can afford, and that we are doing without more and more in order to finance the massive spending machine in Washington. Explain to me WHY we should be shooting ourselves in the foot to embrace an extension to a program that is already going broke with the inevitable conclusion that we locals will end up funding the added expense at the State level!!

    For those who believe that the gov’t will indeed hold up their end of the deal, I say “fool me once, shame on me; fool me twice, shame on you!” Folks, the federal gov’t is B – R – O – K – E !!!! I don’t know how many other ways there are to say it! When inflation finally hits and the interest rates start to rise, as they inevitability will, there is no feasible way to pay the interest on the nat’l debt let alone send money back to Nebraska to fund add’l Medicare and Medicaid expenses!!! Again I ask . . . WHO pays the bill???

    It is TIME to face the truth and stop kidding ourselves: you spend what you don’t HAVE, and you will reap the consequences ten-fold. The bottom line is this: if Nebraskans cannot NOW afford to fund the expansion WITHOUT help from the federal gov’t, why would we want to get involved?

    What will be the consequence to Nebraska if the worst scenario happens and there is NO $$$ coming from D.C.? Remember, there are NO guarantees down the road . . . . the past couple of years we are experienced significant cuts of federal reimbursements for the mandated spending programs instituted in the past! Oh, they PROMISED that they would indeed fund the majority of the programs – little or no cost to local gov’t – BUT where is that $$$$ now? The short answer is that it is coming our of your COUNTY’s budget because there are NO reimbursements coming from Washington!

    HELLO??????

  • ToucheTurtle

    D.Mark, I agree with everything you say except your last sentence: our LEADERS do NOT know the difference . . . . nor do they seem to care!!!!

  • ToucheTurtle

    for HOW LONG. . . . or do YOU care????

  • Pat Boyle

    You all talk like there is no problem. All you ever do is bitch but have no solutions. Coverage costs are insane!! The only reason why we’re not committed to Obamacare yet is because Iowa Gov Terry Braindead said not yet. Gov. Dave never makes a move unless either Johanns or Iowa tells him to.
    A pathetic “leader.”

  • Joan

    Touche, Jazee, Mike Grove and other complainers who are complaining about the “Deadbeats” or “47%” iin our society that they need help, it is your fault they need that help. The last three decades the rich have been getting richer and the middle class has been getting smaller and the poor class is growing. Republicans do not want to fund education, Head Start, WIC, educational grants, teatchers and on and on. They do not believe in science, climate control or saving the planet. They do not believe in allowing a woman to control her own body in cases of rape or incest and you don’t want to care for the life that results from that situation for the next 18 years. Not one of you I dare say has walked in my shoes and cared for a quadriplegic 49 y/o child without insurance and now finally will get Obamacare. Mr Grove, how dare you call me a deadbeat, I have raised my child alone and worked too. Shame on you and all the rest of you.

  • Pat Boyle

    Bitching

  • Pat Boyle

    Solution? Nope, bitching

  • Pat Boyle

    What color is the falling sky in your world?